quartz/content/notes/ethics-essay.md
2022-10-02 09:31:29 +13:00

3.9 KiB

title aliases tags
ethics-essay
cosc203
assignment

specs

2000 words

6 paragaphs

350x4 + 300x2

References

Plan

  • intro
    • about the protests
  • compare and contrast fire and fury with the river of filth
  • about misinformation and censorship
    • relate to videos
  • compare misinformaiton and censoship in each of the videos
  • critiques of fire and fury
  • conclusion

300 words

Intro

As members of society we must consider the ethical implications of our actions and inactions. This extends to our private lives, and our work. As members of the IT profession we have an obligation to adhere to certain standards. These have been collated and formalised into the ACM Code of Ethics. This document "expresses the conscience of the profession", putting human well-being as the main focus. Although it provides a guidline for us to follow, it is not specific to everyone and should merely act as a foundation for individuals, businesses, and governments to build upon.

The recent outbreak of misinformation and censorship, culminating in Aotearoa with the convoy and the Wellington protest in February and March this year, provides an interesting avenue through which we can analyse the spread of information through online channels, and the impact of the computing profession. Many business in the computing sector were key components of the event. For example, Facebook, Gab and Telegram, as well as stuff.co.nz and other news outlets. These organisations have an inherent obligation to consider how their platforms are being used to encourage or discourage the spread of information, regardless of its source and credibility.

I myself do not have the knowledge or experience to make informed decision about what should be allowed on large platforms such as spotify, facebook, and youtube. However, I am able to give my opinion about how misinformation, censorship, and freedom of expression should be balanced. This essay will examine the point of view of the protesters at wellington and contrast it with Stuff's Fire and Fury in an IT context.

Point 1

Throughout history we can observe countless instances of delayed acceptance of medical discoveries. Even the process of resuscitation through mouth to mouth breathing and chest compressions was initally rejected by the public and discouraged. Anti-Vaccination movements existed long before the Covid-19 pandemic. Ever since the first vaccinations REF people have felt uncomfortable. Shorty before Covid-19 struck, Anti Vaccination supporters have protested against the MMR and Measles vaccines. However, following the announcement of the Covid-19 vaccine, these groups gained more followers and start to spread their views, eventually led to the convoy and the wellington protests. They documented their journey in the video titled River of Filth. The video starts with news and articles where the NZ government stated that the vaccine would not be mandatory. Next, they depict the governments betrayl of this promise, forcing 40% of the NZ workforce to be vaccinated. They then showed footage of the convoy, various protests along the way, and the camp out at Wellington parliament CAPS?. The video then finishes with a message condemning the government and mainstream media, and praising the protesters and their efforts

The protesting group was a combination of many parties indcluding, anti vaxers, far right conspircay theoriests, hippie youtubers, and disgruntled citizens. They were upset because the government didn't uphold its promise of non-compulsory covid vaccines.

  • what did they do
  • why were they able to do it
  • what could be have done
  • what should we do in the future

Point 2

From the general populations perspective.

Point 3

contrast

Point 4

tech

Outro

conclusion